You depend on a quality oil filter to protect your engine, so choosing the wrong brand can cost you time and money. This article helps you spot brands that commonly underperform so you can avoid risky filters and keep your engine healthy.
You’ll get practical guidance on warning signs, common problems, and safer alternatives while staying focused on what matters for maintenance and longevity. Keep reading to learn which filters to skip and why they might be a poor fit for your vehicle.
Fram Extra Guard Oil Filter
You might choose Fram Extra Guard for its low price and wide availability.
However, some versions use cardboard end caps that can soften over time in hot oil, which may reduce durability.
You should weigh cost savings against potential longevity issues, especially if you drive frequently or keep your car long-term.
Consider higher-quality filters with metal end caps and better filtration media for more reliable protection.
Supertech Oil Filter
You might see Supertech filters at discount stores and think they’re a bargain.
Many users report inconsistent build quality and weaker sealing compared with name-brand filters, which can increase leak or bypass risk.
If you choose Supertech, inspect the gasket and threads before installation and monitor oil pressure and level after the change.
For long-term reliability, consider upgrading to a filter with stronger filtration media and verified test data.
Frantz Filters
You may see Frantz Filters recommended historically, but quality dropped after the company changed ownership in 2014. Use caution buying older-stock or discount Frantz filters because inconsistent quality control has been reported.
If you choose Frantz, inspect the filter for proper sealing, media integrity, and correct part number for your vehicle. When in doubt, pick a reputable brand with clear specifications and current customer reviews.
Generic No-Name Oil Filters
You might find very cheap no-name filters at discount stores or online marketplaces.
They often cut costs on media quality and sealing, which can let contaminants pass or cause leaks.
Using them risks more frequent filter changes and potential engine wear over time.
Choose filters with clear specifications and reputable testing so your engine gets consistent protection.
Car Manufacturer-Branded Filters (overpriced)
You might pay more for filters sold under a vehicle maker’s name, expecting superior fit or quality.
Often they match OEM specs, but the construction and filtration media can be similar to good aftermarket options.
If you want guaranteed compatibility, an OEM filter simplifies parts matching.
For many drivers, a reputable aftermarket filter gives equal protection at a lower price.
Parts Authority Oil Filter
You might find Parts Authority filters sold at discount, but quality control can vary between batches. That inconsistency can lead to reduced filtration efficiency or fitment issues on some vehicles.
If you choose this brand, inspect the filter for proper sealing and debris inside before installation. Consider reputable alternatives if you want more predictable performance and longer service intervals.
More from Steel Horse Rides: