Plenty of drivers look at electric vehicles as the future, but a growing number of working mechanics are quietly stepping back from the hype. From what they see in the shop, the promise of low maintenance and simple ownership often collides with expensive parts, tricky diagnostics, and customers who feel blindsided by repair bills. When a veteran technician says they would not spend their own money on an EV, it is less about nostalgia and more about what actually fails once the warranty safety net is gone.
That is the tension behind the blunt stance summed up as “I am a mechanic, and I will never buy an electric vehicle.” It is not a blanket rejection of new technology so much as a reaction to how current EVs are built, serviced, and priced, especially around batteries, software, and repair access. In the bay, those choices translate into real-world headaches that do not show up in glossy ads or range charts.
Battery life, replacement shock, and the real cost curve
Every mechanic who has spent time around EVs eventually circles back to the same weak spot, the high-voltage battery pack. On paper, these packs are designed to last for years, but in practice, once capacity drops or a module fails outside warranty, the owner is staring at a repair that can rival the value of the car. That is why one working technician described the battery as “the biggest gamble” in their decision to avoid owning an electric model, a judgment shaped by watching customers wrestle with four- and five-figure estimates tied to a single component.
Those sticker shocks land harder because many buyers walked in believing EVs would be nearly maintenance free. Advertising leans on the lack of oil changes and spark plugs, but it rarely dwells on what happens when a pack needs replacement or a cooling issue shortens its life. Mechanics see the gap between those expectations and the reality of a battery system that is complex, sensitive to heat, and anything but cheap to replace, which is why some now warn that long term ownership costs can be far higher than the early savings suggest, a concern echoed in detailed breakdowns of battery life and replacement bills.
Maintenance myths and the shop-floor reality
There is also frustration in the way EV maintenance gets sold to the public. Mechanics hear customers repeat the line that electric cars barely need service, then watch those same owners get blindsided by brake work, suspension issues, or cooling system repairs that are just as involved as on a gasoline car. The powertrain might have fewer moving parts, but the rest of the vehicle still lives in the same world of potholes, road salt, and worn bushings, and technicians are the ones who have to explain that “low maintenance” does not mean “no maintenance.”
Some of the most pointed criticism from the bay targets the idea that EV upkeep is always cheaper. Once specialized labor, high-voltage safety procedures, and proprietary parts are factored in, the invoice can climb quickly, especially at dealerships that dominate early EV service. That is why one mechanic highlighted how many people assume electric models require almost no attention, only to discover that real-world service is not as inexpensive as some advertisements suggest.
Software, diagnostics, and the disappearing DIY fix
Beyond hardware, the software layer in modern EVs is another reason some mechanics keep their distance as buyers. Traditional cars already rely on scan tools and codes, but electric models take that to a new level, with tightly integrated control units that can turn a simple fault into a complex diagnostic tree. Independent shops often need expensive subscriptions and brand-specific equipment just to talk to these systems, and even then, certain procedures are locked behind factory logins that only dealerships can access.
For a mechanic who grew up fixing vehicles with basic hand tools and a multimeter, that shift feels like a wall going up between owner and machine. Instead of tracing a bad relay or swapping a sensor, they may be forced to replace entire modules because the software will not allow component-level repairs, or because the manufacturer will not sell individual parts. That is why one experienced technician stressed that the new generation of electric cars makes it harder to fix issues independently and economically, a dealbreaker for someone who values being able to maintain their own vehicle.
Training gaps, safety risks, and who gets to work on what
Another underappreciated factor is the training curve. High-voltage systems demand specific procedures, insulated tools, and a healthy respect for what can go wrong if a connector is mishandled. While big dealer networks invest in courses and certifications, many smaller garages are still catching up, and some owners discover that their trusted neighborhood shop simply will not touch their EV. For mechanics, that is not laziness, it is a rational response to the risk of working on a 400- or 800-volt system without full factory support.
That divide shapes how technicians think about owning an electric car themselves. If they cannot confidently service the battery or inverter in their own driveway, and if independent shops are hesitant to take on that work, they are effectively tied to a dealership for major repairs. For a trade built on self-reliance, the idea of being locked into a single service channel is a major turnoff, and it feeds the broader skepticism that leads some mechanics to say they would rather keep driving a gasoline model they can strip down to the last bolt.
Resale worries, real-world use, and why the skepticism sticks
Underneath all the technical talk sits a basic financial worry, what the car will be worth when it is time to move on. Mechanics see how quickly an older EV’s value can collapse once the battery warranty nears its end, because buyers fear inheriting a pack that might fail on their watch. They also see how hard it can be to sell a high-mileage electric hatchback in a market where shoppers are fixated on range numbers and fresh technology, not on how carefully the suspension was maintained.
Layered on top of that are the practical realities of daily use that do not show up in spec sheets. Technicians hear from customers who struggle with public charging, who see range drop in winter, or who discover that towing a small trailer slashes efficiency. When those stories pile up alongside the big-ticket battery jobs and software headaches, it is not surprising that some mechanics decide they are better off sticking with a conventional car for now. Their refusal to buy an EV is less a blanket verdict on the technology and more a grounded reaction to what they see every day, a cautious stance that will only soften if future designs tackle the battery gamble, open up repair access, and give both owners and independent shops a clearer path to keep these cars on the road without breaking the bank.
More from Wilder Media Group: