Here is a little lesson in how wildly classic car prices can swing. One 1965 Ford Falcon Futura sold for $20,000 at an auction, failed to sell just four days later, and then brought $26,500 at the next sale. That is $6,500 more than its first price, in roughly two weeks.

The reporter behind the Ultimate Muscle Car channel was walking an auction lot full of affordable classics when he tracked the Falcon’s wild ride. He says he first saw the car two weeks earlier at the Saratoga auction, where it sold for 20 grand. Four days after that, it turned up at an auction in Nashville, where it did not sell and the high bid was $22,000. At the latest sale, the reserve was lifted when the bid reached $25,000, and the car sold for $26,500.
The Falcon is a white 1965 Futura with a tan top and black wall tires on Ford wheels. Under the hood is a numbers matching 289 that was originally a two-barrel but has been modified and is listed at 275 horsepower, paired to an automatic. Inside, the tan interior has a bench seat, a power top and a floor shifter.
The Cars That Went Up
The Falcon was not the only car with a story. A 1963 Pontiac Catalina was at the lot in April, painted cameo ivory, with a 389 two-barrel rated at 267 horsepower and a two-speed automatic. Back then, the auction closed without a sale and the high bid was $13,500. The car was then listed with a dealer at an asking price of $19,988, and it sat there until this auction, where it sold for $20,000.
A 1972 Chevy Custom 20 pickup shows the gap between asking prices and what bidders pay. The truck has a white top, blue body, the factory 402 big block and a Turbo 400 automatic, plus heavy-duty suspension, eight-lug wheels, new tires, power front disc brakes and factory AC. The reporter saw it for sale a few blocks from the auction with an asking price of $26,900. The next day at auction, the reserve came off at $19,750, and that is what it sold for.
Another example is a 1963 Mercury Comet S22, the top trim package for 1963, with a 289 and recent upgrades including front disc brakes, a carburetor, alternator and electronic distributor. It was listed online for $19,900 before the sale, but at auction the reserve was lifted at $14,000 and it sold for that amount.
The Cars That Went Down
Some of the best lessons come from cars that sold for less than before. A 1962 Oldsmobile Starfire in white with a burgundy top and a 394 V8 rated at 345 horsepower sold at an auction nine months earlier for $22,000. This time the reserve was lifted at $19,500 and that is what it sold for, $2,500 less.
A rare Arcadian blue Ford Mustang with a 289 two-barrel C code engine rated at 200 horsepower, a bench seat and a four-speed on the floor, a combination the reporter says you never see, did even worse. It sold for $27,000 in April. Six months later, the reserve was lifted at $23,000 and it sold for $23,000, which is $4,000 less.
A Few More Results From The Lot
- 1964 Ford Galaxie 500 XL, 390 engine rated at 300 horsepower: reserve lifted at $11,250, sold for $12,750.
- 1963 Chevy Impala SS, black, 350 with a four-speed: sold at $36,000.
- 1969 AMC AMX in Beale Street blue, modified 401 with a four-speed: sold for $39,500.
- 1956 Thunderbird, restored in yellow, 312 V8: reserve lifted at $25,500, sold for $27,000.
- 1977 Cadillac coupe with a 425: sold for $4,000 at the Saratoga auction two weeks earlier, and $5,000 at this one with no reserve.
Other results ranged widely. A 1969 Ford Mustang restored about six years ago, with an inline six, sold for $14,500, and a 1969 Toronado with a 455 went for $12,000. A 1962 Plymouth Fury with a ton of recent maintenance sold for $8,250, a 1982 El Camino SS Royal Knight reached $18,000, a 1969 Corvette in Monza red sold for $16,250, and an unrestored 1962 Ford Galaxie XL with factory AC and power everything reached $28,000.
What Buyers Can Take Away
The big takeaway is that the same car can bring very different money in a matter of days. The Falcon moved from $20,000 to a no-sale with a $22,000 high bid to $26,500, all with the same Futura and the same 289 under the hood. A reserve, which is the minimum price a seller will accept, can be lifted mid-bid, and that is what happened on most of these cars.
If you are shopping for a classic at auction, the lot offers a few reminders:
- Compare an asking price with what similar cars actually sold for, since the Chevy truck and the Comet both sold well under their listings.
- Watch a car sell more than once if you can. A no-sale with a high bid tells you what the market would not pay yet.
- Remember that rare options such as a bench seat with a four-speed do not guarantee a higher price.
The reporter closed by asking which car on the lot people liked best. For the Falcon, the answer is clear in the numbers: a few days and a different set of bidders were worth an extra $6,500.
More Stories You May Like
- Pete Borrowed About 500 Dollars From Mom To Get Their Stolen 1978 Trans Am Back Then Sold It For Salvage And 40 Years Later Finally Sees The Rebuilt Dream Car
- Buyer Spends Three Days Convincing The Owner To Sell An Abandoned Mitsubishi 3000GT Then Pumps The Clutch For 20 Minutes To Get It Home
- Couple Who Bought A Classic MGB With No Experience Fixed Its Dim Dash Lights By Swapping In LED Bulbs That Made Them Significantly Brighter
