Estate Sale 1956 Chrysler New Yorker St. Regis Is Rotting Away, And A Full Restoration Could Cost Six Figures Though No St. Regis Is Known To Have Sold For More Than $50,000

The black roof is still there. So is a white-over-red body with the ghost of a three-tone finish. But the trunk lid is gone, the passenger door is gone, much of the interior is gone, and so is the original drivetrain. This is a 1956 Chrysler New Yorker St. Regis, and it has seen better days.

An old blue car left to decay in a field.

The hardtop was spotted at an estate sale, according to Autoevolution. After sitting for decades and being picked for parts, it is a sad sight. The writer asked a hard question: is a car like this worth restoring?

Missing The Trunk Lid, A Door, The Interior And The Engine

The St. Regis rolled off the assembly line in a three-tone finish, with a black roof over a white-on-red body. The writer bet it was a gorgeous sight when it was new.

Now the car is missing its trunk lid and the passenger door, as well as much of the interior. The original drivetrain was removed too. Little is left but the shape and the colors.

A Rotisserie Restoration Could Run To Six Figures

So is it worth restoring? According to the report, not really. A rotisserie restoration could cost up to six figures today, and these Mopars do not fetch nearly as much in perfect condition at public auctions.

The writer said he has seen only a couple go for over $40,000, and a few others reached into the $30,000 range. As far as he knows, no St. Regis has fetched more than $50,000, although the rarest New Yorker convertibles have on a few occasions.

That math is brutal. A buyer could spend more on the work than the finished car would ever bring.

The Name Came From A Limousine That Started The Forward Look

The New Yorker was introduced in 1940 and stayed in continuous production through 1996, minus the World War II years. It was the brand’s flagship and is Chrysler’s longest-running nameplate. It also spawned a few cool limited editions, including the St. Regis.

The most recent Mopar with the St. Regis badge was a Dodge, a full-size car sold from 1979 to 1981. The badge also graced the New Yorker twice: once from 1974 to 1978, and originally in 1955 and 1956.

The St. Regis arrived on the fourth-generation New Yorker, a significant departure from the model before it. The 1955 luxury car was based on the custom 1952 Imperial Parade Phaeton limo, penned by Virgil Exner. The styling kicked off the Forward Look era, which lasted through 1961.

Two-Tone Paint, Extra Chrome And A Textured Headliner

The St. Regis badge was reserved for two-door hardtops with exclusive two-tone paint, and the options list also included a choice of three-tone schemes. The package added a bit of extra chrome trim, a textured vinyl headliner, cloth upholstery inserts and a color-keyed cabin.

What it did not add was performance. The St. Regis was about style and comfort, not speed.

Not Rare By The Numbers, But Rare To See

The St. Regis was somewhat popular for a luxury car in 1955. Of 52,178 New Yorkers delivered, exactly 11,076 had St. Regis badges, a little over 21% of the total. In 1956, New Yorker deliveries dropped to 41,140, and the St. Regis found 6,686 homes, or 16%.

So the St. Regis is not rare by production numbers. It is a rare sight today because most of them are rotting away in junkyards and backyards, much like this one.

Restore It, Part It Out Or Let It Go?

The writer asked whether this hardtop has a future in any form, or whether it should be parted out and sent to the crusher. It is a fair question, and the answer depends on the person asking.

For a buyer who loves the Forward Look era and has patience, a car like this can be a source of rare trim and parts for another St. Regis. For a buyer who wants to drive something nice, it is a long road.

There is also an emotional side to the question. Cars from the Forward Look era have a certain swagger, with their tall fins, big chrome and bold color breaks, and plenty of hobbyists would hate to see another one disappear. Others point out that a car stripped of its engine, door and trunk lid is closer to a pile of parts than a project.

The honest answer is that both views have merit. If the plan is to build a showpiece, the numbers say it is a money-loser. If the plan is to keep a rare body from the crusher, the car may still have a role to play.

Before You Buy A Project With Parts Missing

Many readers have seen a car like this in a field and wondered. A few questions help.

Compare restoration cost to finished value. If a car brings $30,000 to $40,000 when perfect, a six-figure rebuild does not make sense.
Count the missing parts. A missing door, trunk lid and drivetrain add up fast on a rare model.
Know why you want it. A labor-of-love project is different from an investment.
Think about saving the parts. Even a rough car can help keep better ones on the road.

The St. Regis once symbolized the best Chrysler had to offer. Today it is a reminder that not every classic gets a happy ending.

Steel Horse Rides