A 2001 Honda Civic rolled into the bay at Royalty Auto Service with 288,000 miles on the odometer and a problem its owner had been chasing for years. It ran fine until it reached operating temperature, then after 20 to 30 minutes of driving it started to overheat. She would pull over, let it cool and add coolant again.

A mechanic using a small flashlight to inspect the engine of a car in a workshop

The backstory, which the mechanic read aloud from the owner’s notes, was a long one. “I love notes like that,” he said, because every line pointed somewhere.

A Timing Belt Snapped, And A First-Timer Decided To Rebuild The Top End Herself

According to the notes, a friend was driving the Civic when the timing belt broke. The owner stripped the engine down, pulled the cylinder head and took it to a machine shop, where about eight intake and exhaust valves were replaced.

It was her first time ever doing a head gasket, let alone a timing belt. She ordered a full engine gasket kit, a water pump and a new belt while the shop worked on the head.

The mechanic pointed out that the machine shop never told her to strip everything off the head first. When it came back, parts were missing, including the timing gear, which she ended up tracking down at a junkyard.

“The Dowel Pins. That’s A Big, Big Thing.” Two Small Pieces Of Metal Were Missing

Then came the detail that made the shop crew stop and sit up. As she started putting the engine back together, the owner noticed the dowel pins were gone.

Dowel pins are the little alignment pins that sit in the block and keep the head and head gasket lined up. She Googled, made some phone calls and decided to go ahead without them.

Her workaround was clever in its way. A friend held the head while she dropped two new head bolts through the bolt holes, started them hand tight and lowered the head down slowly, calling out “Going down, going down.” She torqued everything to the specs she found online and went for a test drive.

Cam Timing Codes, A Limp Mode And A Belt Moved “A Tooth Or Two”

She was happy at first. Then the car threw cam timing codes and dropped into limp mode.

She replaced the cam sensor, which did nothing. She then took the timing area apart again and repositioned the belt on the cam gear by what she thinks was a tooth or two. After that the car drove great.

The temperature, though, started creeping up. She replaced the temperature sensor, figuring it was original. Then her job sent her to Massachusetts, and the Civic sat for almost two years.

Pulling The Plugs And Pressure Testing The Cooling System Told The Story Fast

Back home, she was still adding coolant constantly. The shop decided not to even drive the car. The mechanic said the dowel pins were their first suspect and they wanted to test that idea right away.

His theory was not a blown head gasket exactly. “It’s not blown. It’s shifted,” he explained, because without the pins the gasket can move a little, and with expansion and contraction things shift around. The test plan was simple: pull the coils and plugs, pressurize the cooling system and look into each cylinder with a borescope.

They topped off the low coolant and pressurized the system to about 1.1 bar, which he noted is a little over 14 pounds. Before the plugs even came out, he gave her credit. “I’m not seeing a whole bunch of stuff left loose,” he said, and it looked like “a fairly decent job.”

The spark plugs were not very tight, and the first plug showed nothing obvious. Then the borescope went into the first cylinder.

“Look at that coolant in there,” one of them said. Green fluid was visible in one cylinder. Another showed a little dampness by the rings. In a third, coolant started dripping down and the view fogged up “like this morning outside.”

“That sucks,” the mechanic said. “It’s what we thought.” He added that this was not the first time the shop had seen missing dowel pins cause exactly this. Even one missing pin, he said, can let the head shift enough to cause trouble.

The Fix Is Another Head Gasket, Plus Dowel Pins And A Look At The Cylinder Walls

His advice for the owner was straightforward. Pull the head, have a machine shop check that it is not warped, and if it is flat, no machine work is needed. Put on a new head gasket with the dowel pins in place, reuse the timing belt and reinstall the parts she missed. The upper timing cover, for example, was never put back on.

The owner told the shop she never let the car overheat, and it ran well afterward. That is good news for a 288,000 mile engine. In bonus footage, the crew did note that one cylinder wall looked a little worn and that coolant is a poor lubricant, so the head should be removed with a close look at the walls before spending money on gaskets.

The mechanic’s closing thought was the part worth repeating. “This engine didn’t do anything wrong,” he said. The timing belt broke because the belt was never replaced on schedule. If it had been done when it was supposed to be, the engine would still be perfectly fine.

What Home Mechanics Can Take From This Honda

The shop did not scold her. They called the job decent for a beginner, and the mechanic told a story about pulling a transmission from his 1968 Mustang as a teenager and forgetting the pilot bushing. He had to tear it all apart again the next morning. “The hardest lessons are the ones you remember,” he said, and the second time through is always quicker.

If you are tackling a head gasket job yourself, a few lessons stand out from this one.

  • Strip the head of the cam, cam gears and sensors before it goes to a machine shop, since shops do not want those parts.
  • Keep the dowel pins safe when you pull the head, and replace any that get mangled. Do not start the job without them.
  • Replace the timing belt on the maker’s schedule. A snapped belt can start this whole chain of repairs.
  • If a car loses coolant with no visible leak, a cooling system pressure test followed by a look in the cylinders can find the answer in minutes.

The channel asked viewers to share their own first time taking something apart, and whether they had to do it twice. For this Civic owner, the answer looks to be yes.

More Stories You May Like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *