You’re probably paying more to keep a car than you did a year or two ago — and that jump isn’t the same everywhere. Some states have seen costs climb faster because of higher insurance, fuel, taxes, or repair bills. If you live in or are shopping for a car in states like Nevada, Florida, or Louisiana, expect noticeably steeper annual ownership costs.
This post breaks down where those increases are largest and why they matter to your wallet, from insurance premiums to sales tax and rising repair prices. Stay tuned to see which specific costs push your total higher and what that means for your next car decision.
Where Vehicle Ownership Costs Are Rising the Fastest
You’ll see the steepest increases where insurance, fuel, and registration climb together. Expect some states to jump much faster than the national pace because of local insurance markets and higher driving mileage.
Top States With the Highest Yearly Ownership Expenses
Delaware, Georgia, and New Mexico show some of the largest yearly totals in recent analyses. Delaware tops several lists with annual costs exceeding $7,400 due to very high gas spending and heavy annual mileage that drives maintenance up.
Georgia’s total hovers near $6,000 annually, mainly because auto insurance premiums are the nation’s highest there.
New Mexico and Maine also appear on high-cost rosters because their insurance premiums and fuel expenses outpace neighboring states.
If you track the most expensive states to own a car, watch for those where registration fees combine with steep insurance and fuel — that trio multiplies your annual car ownership cost quickly.
Dominant Drivers of Price Hikes by State
Insurance premiums lead the increases in many states; where average car insurance rises, your annual cost follows. States such as Georgia and Maine report insurance as the single largest swing factor.
Gas prices and miles driven push maintenance and fuel totals higher in states like Delaware. High driving mileage magnifies wear-and-tear costs and makes fuel-price volatility more painful for you.
Vehicle taxes and registration changes can create sudden jumps. Mississippi’s high registration examples show how a policy tweak can add hundreds to your bill.
Sales tax on cars and local fees also matter: even modest hikes on a high purchase price translate into larger five-year ownership costs.
Cost Differences Compared to National Averages
You’ll pay well above the national median in the priciest states. The national median for recurring annual expenses often sits near $4,000; Delaware can exceed that by more than $3,000.
Insurance spreads drive much of the gap: states range from about $900 to nearly $3,000 annually for insurance alone. That variance explains most state-to-state differences in your total car ownership cost.
On the low end, states like Iowa and Montana keep yearly totals near the low $3,000s through cheaper insurance, lower gas costs, and less driving.
When you compare your state to the national average, focus first on insurance and gas — those two line items create the largest deviations from the median.
Breaking Down the Costs: What’s Making Vehicle Ownership So Expensive?
You’re paying more every year for the basics: insurance, fuel, maintenance, taxes, and a raft of smaller fees. Each line item bites into your monthly budget in different ways, so it helps to see which costs are rising fastest and why.
Soaring Car Insurance Premiums
Insurance rates jumped sharply in many states after 2021, driven by higher repair costs and more frequent claims. If you live where repair bills are high or where accident rates rose, your premiums will reflect that; AAA and other analyses show increases that pushed national averages into the low thousands per year.
Your driving record, credit (where allowed), vehicle value, and the local frequency of claims all influence what you pay. Luxury and newer vehicles cost more to insure because replacement parts and advanced driver-assist systems are expensive to fix.
Ways to reduce costs: raise deductibles, compare companies every year, bundle policies, and ask about discounts for safety features or low-mileage. Check your state’s typical premiums to set realistic expectations — some states now average well over $1,500 yearly for full coverage.
Rising Fuel and Gas Prices
Fuel is one of the most visible and volatile ownership costs you face. National averages fluctuate with oil markets, refinery outages, and seasonal demand; a few cents-per-gallon swing can change your monthly spend by tens or hundreds of dollars depending on how much you drive.
Your vehicle’s fuel economy matters: at 25 mpg, driving 15,000 miles costs far more in gas than an efficient hybrid at 50+ mpg. EV owners still pay to charge, but home charging usually costs less per mile than public fast chargers. Public DC fast-charging rates can exceed $0.60/kWh in some areas, narrowing the savings compared with gasoline in places with cheap power.
Reduce fuel expense by choosing higher-MPG cars, combining trips, using apps to find cheaper local stations, and shifting most charging to home if you drive an EV.
Taxes, Maintenance, and Repair Costs
State sales tax, registration fees, and annual vehicle property taxes directly add to the cost of ownership. Some states tack on EV or hybrid surcharges to replace lost gas-tax revenue. These predictable charges compound your yearly budget and vary widely by location.
Maintenance and repairs have climbed because replacement parts and labor cost more now. AAA data and industry reports show average maintenance and repair spending near $1,400–$1,500 per year for a typical driver, though that depends on vehicle age and miles driven. Older cars often need more frequent, costly repairs; newer cars can have expensive electronics and specialized service.
You can lower expenses with preventive maintenance, choosing models with strong reliability records, and shopping around for independent mechanics rather than dealer service centers.
Extra Fees and Hidden Expenses
Beyond the headline items, small recurring fees accumulate fast. Think parking permits, tolls, emission and inspection charges, and higher insurance for younger drivers or those with spacing infractions. Loan interest on higher-priced cars adds thousands in extra cost over the life of a loan, especially at today’s elevated APRs.
Depreciation is a major hidden cost: new cars can lose 20%+ of value in the first year and more in the following years, which affects trade-in value and insurance replacement costs. Accessories, aftermarket tires, extended warranties, and gap insurance are optional but often marketed at purchase and increase your monthly outlay.
Track these extras in a simple monthly spreadsheet to see the real cost of your vehicle and identify easy cuts.
More from Steel Horse Rides: