If your car has a touch screen, a cellular antenna and an app on your phone, there is a good chance it has been taking notes on how you drive. General Motors just agreed to pay $220 million over exactly that, and longtime mechanic Scotty Kilmer says the whole thing is proof that carmakers treat drivers like “a walking ATM machine instead of a customer.”

A view from inside a car driving down a misty highway at night

Kilmer, who says he has worked on cars for more than 50 years, laid out the story in a recent video. His complaint is not only that GM got caught. It is where the money is going.

35 State Attorneys General And Washington DC Went After GM And Walked Away With $220 Million

According to Kilmer, 35 state attorneys general plus Washington DC sued GM, and the company agreed to pay $220 million. He points out that GM did not admit any wrongdoing, which is common in settlements of this kind.

The New York attorney general’s office announced its part of the deal on October 29, 2026, and said a bipartisan group of states took part. Its release puts New York’s share at $12,054,341.

The allegation is that GM collected driving information from people without their real understanding and sold it, through data brokers, to insurance companies. The insurers could then adjust premiums based on how a person drove, even a driver with no claims.

“Your Car Was Spying On You” Through A Program Called Smart Driver

The program at the center of it is called Smart Driver, part of GM’s OnStar system and its apps. It ran from 2016 to 2024. GM described it as a free safety tool to help drivers improve, but Kilmer says “in reality, your car was spying on you.”

He describes what it recorded: when your trip started and ended, where you went by GPS, every time you went over 80 miles an hour and how hard you accelerated and braked. The New York release lists trip counts, start and end times, hard braking, rapid acceleration and speeding.

Kilmer’s point is that the numbers miss the context. A slam on the brakes because someone cut you off looks the same in the data as sloppy driving. “It makes you look like a bad driver cuz you had to slam your brakes on,” he says, and there is no video to show who was really at fault.

Some Drivers Saw Insurance Rates Jump 50, 60 Even 80% After The Car Told On Them

That is where the real cost comes in. Kilmer says some GM drivers had their insurance rates “jacked up 50, 60, even 80%” because of what their cars reported. He adds that rates can follow you into other costs, like the interest rate on your next car loan.

The New York attorney general’s office pointed to one example from a 2024 investigation of a driver who was told a 22% increase was tied to data from a broker. That driver’s report ran 130 pages and covered six months of driving.

Kilmer says the data went to big information companies, and he names LexisNexis and Verisk, which then sold it to insurers. The state release says the brokers’ contracts stated the data would be used for insurance products.

370,000 Drivers Were Told They Were Not Enrolled While The Data Kept Flowing

Here is the part Kilmer calls “the real rotten one.” Some drivers were smart enough to open the app and opt out. A total of 370,000 of them did, and the app told them they were not enrolled.

It was wrong. According to the New York release, the OnStar app wrongly told more than 370,000 drivers they were not enrolled in Smart Driver. GM later unenrolled them without letting them know about the error, and their data stayed with brokers and insurers.

“They even lied to them,” Kilmer says. GM, he adds, was collecting and selling information even after telling people it was not.

Dealers Got Bonuses For Signing You Up, And Many Drivers Never Knew They Signed Anything

How did so many people end up in the program? Kilmer says most never realized they had joined anything. The state release agrees, saying most drivers enrolled at the dealership when buying a vehicle through a single sign-up that covered Smart Driver and OnStar.

The release also alleges that dealership staff accepted terms on customers’ behalf without consent, and that from 2020 to 2024 GM gave dealership employees bonuses based partly on enrollment numbers. Kilmer puts it in plain terms: “Oh, it’s a safety feature. Here, just sign. It’s free.”

“It Is Going To Lawyers And The Government” Is Kilmer’s Gripe About The $220 Million

Kilmer’s biggest complaint is the check itself. “Is that money going back to you and me for refunds?” he asks. His answer: “No. It’s going to lawyers and to the government.” He calls it a raw deal. The New York release lists the state’s share and describes the settlement terms, and it describes rules GM now has to follow, including limits on the driving data it can collect and a requirement for a data privacy program with outside review.

How To Shut The Spying Down On Your Own Car, Straight From A Mechanic

Kilmer says other makers collect data too. He says his own Toyota has such a system, but as a mechanic he turned it off. Here is what he recommends.

  • Open your car’s app, go to the privacy or connected services menu and revoke every permission tied to driving behavior, driving score or insurance discounts.
  • Skip any insurance app or plug in device that promises lower rates. Kilmer says they are used to raise rates, and he warns that cheap devices plugged into the diagnostic port can cause stalling and electrical trouble.
  • Ask for your LexisNexis consumer report. Kilmer says by law you can get it once a year and it shows whether your manufacturer has been sending your driving data into the system.
  • If the car is out of warranty, he suggests finding the telematics fuse and pulling it. The catch is that remote start from your phone will stop working.

He also recommends a good dash cam, so there is real proof of who was at fault if anything happens.

Kilmer’s closing message is blunt: “You’re not paranoid. Your modern day car is spying on you.” Check your settings this week, before your next renewal notice does the talking.

More Stories You May Like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *