The pitch usually comes after a long day at the dealership, when you are tired, hungry and ready to sign anything that gets you out the door. That is exactly when a car service contract lands on the desk.

The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) says these contracts are optional and can be expensive. Its consumer advice on auto warranties and service contracts, published in 2023, lays out what to ask first, and we have turned it into eight checks.
These contracts are often called “extended warranties,” but the FTC points out that because you buy one separately, it is not a warranty as defined by federal law. It is a different thing from the add-ons a dealer may fold into your loan, and it deserves its own set of questions.
1. Find Out Who Actually Stands Behind The Contract
The FTC says to learn whether the manufacturer, the dealer or an independent company is the provider. Get the answer in writing.
It also notes that administrators often decide claim payments, so read the contract to learn your rights if a claim is turned down.
There is a safety net of sorts. The FTC says that if the administrator goes out of business, the dealer may have to do the work, and if the dealer goes out of business, the administrator might be required to fulfill the contract.
2. Compare It To The Factory Warranty You Already Have
The FTC says to compare the contract with the manufacturer’s warranty and to check the coverage dates. A contract that starts before the warranty expires probably will not help you.
A 2018 CFPB blog written with the FTC puts the same worry as a question: does it duplicate the manufacturer’s warranty?
3. If An Item Is Missing From The List, Assume You Are On Your Own
The FTC says contracts typically leave out accident damage and normal wear and tear. A promise of coverage for only “mechanical breakdowns” may exclude wear and tear as well.
The 2018 CFPB blog gives blunt guidance: “if an item isn’t listed, assume it’s not covered.” It adds that few contracts cover all repairs, and that parts like brakes and clutches are often excluded.
The blog also warns that you may have to pay labor if a mechanic must tear down an engine and finds parts outside the contract.
4. Ask Where You Can Get The Car Fixed
Some contracts let you pick among service centers, while others require the selling dealer, according to the FTC. Ask whether you need pre-approval for repairs or towing.
The agency also suggests asking whether the contract will still be useful if you move.
5. Read The Fine Print On Maintenance Duties
The FTC says a contract may require you to follow the manufacturer’s maintenance recommendations. Falling behind might void your coverage.
Keep service records and receipts for oil changes, tire rotations and inspections, because the company may ask for them. Missing records could lead to a denied claim.
On the factory warranty itself, the FTC says it is illegal for a dealer to deny coverage because someone else did your routine maintenance or repairs. Hang on to every receipt anyway.
6. Know How Claims Are Filed And How Fast You Get Paid
The FTC says the contract should explain how to file a claim, how reimbursement works and how long it takes. If it does not, ask before you sign.
The agency also recommends asking about towing and rental car payments, depreciation factors that reduce payouts, and caps on mechanic labor.
7. Add Up The Real Cost, Including Deductibles
According to the FTC, prices range from several hundred to several thousand dollars. The cost depends on whether the vehicle is new or used, its make and model, what is covered and how long the contract lasts.
You may also owe a deductible for each service or repair. The CFPB blog says dealer extended warranties can add hundreds of dollars, sometimes over $1,000, plus financing costs.
Add it all up before you decide. A contract that costs a few thousand dollars and rarely pays out is no bargain, and one that matches your real risks might be.
8. Check The Length, Transfer Rules And Cancellation Terms
The FTC says to check whether you can transfer the contract when you sell the vehicle, whether a fee applies, and whether a shorter contract is available.
The CFPB blog adds two simple questions to your list: how long does it last, and can it be cancelled?
One more warning from the FTC. Scammers may call, text or mail, sometimes long after you bought the vehicle, with a “Final Warranty Notice” that says your warranty is expiring. Those companies probably are not working with your dealer or manufacturer, and they may push for personal financial information and a down payment before telling you what the contract says.
A March 2023 FTC consumer alert on a settlement with American Vehicle Protection adds a rule of thumb: get the coverage details in writing before paying, and search the company name with the words “review” or “complaint.” If something goes wrong, the FTC says to contact your dealer and the contract company first, then your state attorney general or ReportFraud.ftc.gov.
More Stories You May Like
- Extended Warranty Fine Print Often Leaves Out Wear Items And Prior Repairs, So Read The Exclusions Before You Sign Anything That Says Covered
- Odometer Rollbacks And Mismatched Vehicle Histories Can Make A Used Car Look Far Better Than It Is, So Check The Records And Service History Before You Trust The Mileage
- Mechanic Who Sat Behind The Service Desk For 20 Years Says He Still Drives A 15 Year Old Car And Names The Eight Cars He Would Buy Today While The Good Ones Last
